The short answer
- Shingle costs the least upfront and goes on fastest.
- Tile (clay or concrete) is the classic South Florida look and lasts a long time when it's installed well.
- Metal costs the most, but it usually lasts the longest and usually has the highest wind ratings.
- Every permitted roof in Palm Beach and Broward has to meet the Florida Building Code wind rules for its address, whatever the material.
How do they compare?
| Roof | Relative cost | Wind rating | Typical life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shingle | 2 out of 5 | Up to 130 mph wind warranty | About 20–30 years |
| Clay or concrete tile | 4 out of 5 | 125+ mph when properly attached | About 20–30 years |
| Metal | 5 out of 5 | 140 mph and up, depending on the panel | 30+ years |
Cost is the installed price compared with the other roofs, from $ (lowest) to $$$$$ (highest). Lifespans are what we see on South Florida jobs. For every roof type we install, including flat roofs, see our Roof Types page.
What do the wind ratings mean?
Each material is tested in a different way, so treat the numbers as a rough guide, not a ranking. A shingle's "130 mph" is usually the manufacturer's wind rating or warranty for that product. That isn't the same thing as the design wind speed the building code sets for your address.
What matters most is the whole system: the product, the nailing or attachment, the underlayment and the edges. A well-installed roof of any of these materials can meet Florida code. A poorly installed one can fail in a storm.
Is it different in Broward than in Palm Beach?
Yes. Broward County is in Florida's High Velocity Hurricane Zone, along with Miami-Dade. That means stricter product approvals and installation rules. Palm Beach County follows the regular Florida Building Code wind rules, which are still strict near the coast. Your roofer should pull a permit and use products approved for your county.
Which roof helps with insurance?
- Age limits are longer for "hard" roofs. Citizens Insurance starts extra roof checks at 25 years for shingle roofs, but at 50 years for tile and metal. A tile or metal roof can stay insurable longer.
- Wind mitigation features count for any material. A wind mitigation inspection looks at things like how the roof deck is nailed, the straps that tie the roof to the walls, and a sealed underlayment. These features may lower your premium.
- Shape matters too. Hip roofs (sloped on all four sides) generally hold up better in wind than gable roofs, and inspections note the difference.
Ask your insurance agent how a new roof would affect your premium before you choose.
What drives the price?
- The size and pitch of your roof.
- The material and style you pick.
- Rotten wood or damage we find under the old roof.
- Permits and inspections, which are stricter in Broward.
- Upgrades like peel-and-stick underlayment or new roof straps.
A written quote from a free inspection is the only way to know your real number.
Tile, metal or shingle: which roof is right for me?
There is no single best roof for every Florida home. The right one depends on your budget, how long you'll stay, your HOA, and your house. Use this quick guide:
| If this sounds like you | Look at | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You want the lowest upfront cost | Shingle | Lowest price and fastest install. Ask for the maker's matching starter strip and ridge caps, which most shingle wind warranties require. |
| You may sell within 5 to 10 years | Shingle or tile | A new roof helps a sale and an insurance quote. You may not get back the extra cost of metal. |
| You plan to stay 20+ years | Metal or tile | Longer life means fewer re-roofs. Insurers also give "hard" roofs a longer age limit. |
| Your HOA requires a certain look | Usually tile | Many South Florida HOAs require clay or concrete tile. Check your HOA rules before you choose. |
| You live close to the ocean | Tile or aluminum | Within about a mile of the ocean or the Intracoastal we recommend aluminum, not steel. Ask about fasteners made for salt air. |
| You want the toughest roof in a hurricane | Metal | Usually the highest wind ratings, and no tiles to crack. |
| Your house is older, or you're unsure the frame can carry weight | Shingle or metal | Tile is heavy. Switching to tile can mean an engineer's check. |
| Your home is only here part of the year | Metal or tile | Less upkeep while you're away. Still have it checked after big storms. |
Whatever you choose, ask about upgrades that make any roof stronger: peel-and-stick underlayment, extra deck nailing, and roof-to-wall straps. These are the same upgrades a wind mitigation inspection looks for. If your home was built before 2008, check whether you qualify for My Safe Florida Home before you sign.
How Bravo's Roofing can help
We install shingle, tile, metal and flat roofs across Palm Beach and Broward. We'll look at your home, explain your options side by side, and give you a written quote. No pressure, no sales pitch.
Hablamos español. Wind ratings vary by product and installation, and costs are relative, not quotes. Information is current as of November 2026.



